by Anthony Persico
Tracking the Top 10 Aaron Judge Rookie Cards and Their Worth
Baseball cards are more than just pieces of cardboard with photos printed on them. To true collectors, they are a piece of history and a relic of the spectacular feats of the players they admire and root for.
And very few modern MLB players have inspired as much admiration and awe as the New York Yankees right-fielder, #99, Aaron Judge, which is why his rookie card is highly desirable as both a collector’s item and investment.
The Aaron Judge Rookie Card Trend
Since his Major League Baseball debut with the Yankees in 2016, Aaron Judge has won the hearts of Yankees fans (and MLB fans in general) with his imposing physical stature (he stands 6 feet, 7 inches tall), outstanding defensive skills and arm strength, and most notably, his incredible home run power
Judge’s exceptional skill and charisma, combined with the fact that he plays for one of the most popular and well-known professional sports teams in the world, The New York Yankees, has made his rookie card one of the most sought after of any professional athlete.
In fact, the Aaron Judge rookie card has been trending since his 2017 season when he won American League Rookie of the Year by batting .284 with 52 home runs and an OPS of 1.049. Since then, the value of his rookie cards have continued to climb over the years and early investors were further rewarded in 2022 when Judge blasted 62 home runs, breaking the American League single-season record and earning him his first career MVP award.
So, what are the most valuable and coveted Aaron Judge rookie cards? Here are our top ten:
Disclaimer: This post is meant to celebrate and highlight Judge’s most popular rookie cards. This is not financial or investment advice. When investing in sports cards, it's essential to consider the card's condition and grading, and to purchase from reputable sources. The prices can vary significantly based on these factors and the current demand in the market.
1.) 2013 Bowman Draft Picks Aaron Judge Rookie Card #BDPP19
The Bowman base or Chrome-version is a must-have rookie card for any serious Aaron Judge collector. This 1st Bowman card displays a youthful Judge in a powerful stance foreboding the prolific power hitter he will eventually become.
The 2013 Bowman Draft Picks Aaron Judge rookie card is the very first card of Aaron Judge in a Yankees uniform ever produced.
2.) 2017 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge Rookie Card #169
The very first Aaron Judge Topps rookie card features him during his rookie season and is a favorite amongst collectors who seek to hold his debut Topps baseball card.
Note that there is also a short-print variant version of the 2017 Aaron Judge Topps rookie card with a photo of him running the bases that is also highly coveted.
3.) 2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge Rookie Card US166
This Aaron Judge rookie card Topps mid-season release shows judge during his historic 2017 season where he would slug 52 home runs and win the AL Rookie of the Year Award and finish 2nd in the AL MVP voting.
The 2017 Topps Update also includes a short-print photo variant version.
4.) 2013 Panini Elite Extra Edition Aaron Judge Rookie Card #122
This Aaron Judge rookie card does not feature him in a Yankees uniform, but it remains sought after due to its limited release and variants that include a die-cut and autographed version, making it a valuable addition to any collection.
5.) 2017 Topps Heritage Aaron Judge Rookie Card #214
Two of Judge’s most popular early cards are his 2017 Tops Heritage Rookie Card #214 and his sophomore 2018 Rookie Cup Card #25 because of their throwback designs that pay homage to Judge’s talent and the rich history of baseball cards, making this Aaron Judge Topps rookie card and rookie card cup great additions to any collection.
6.) 2017 Bowman Chrome Aaron Judge Rookie Card #56
Bowman Chrome rookie cards are always popular among baseball card collectors, and Judge's 2017 Bowman Chrome rookie card is no exception.
7.) 2013 Panini Prizm Draft Picks Aaron Judge Rookie Card #131
The 2013 Panini Prizm Draft Picks set includes a few of Judge’s very first cards. For fans who don’t mind that he is not featured in a Yankees uniform, the set offers base card #131 as well as a Prospects Signatures autograph insert #33, both of which are must-haves for any investor trying to collect all of Judge’s rookie cards.
8.) 2017 Topps Allen & Ginter Aaron Judge Rookie Card #172
The Allen & Ginter set has a vintage design that greatly stands out from other 2017 baseball cards.
9.) 2017 Topps Stadium Club Aaron Judge Rookie Card #64
Known for its exceptional photography, Topps Stadium Club rookie cards are always a fan favorite and the especially clean 2017 design featured during Judge’s rookie season makes this card of the most visually stunning Aaron Judge rookie cards on this list.
10.) 2017 Donruss Optic Aaron Judge Rated Rookie Card #38
This Aaron Judge rookie card is a part of the ever-popular "Rated Rookie" series from Donruss and is a desirable addition to many Judge card collections.
What is the Best Aaron Judge Rookie Card?
While all of the above Aaron Judge rookie cards are sought-after, it is not the base cards, but the short-print (often autographed) variants in excellent condition (graded a 9 or higher by a reputable grading company such as BGS, PSA, or SGC) that are typically considered to have the most worth and resale value.
In our opinion, limited print SP versions of the 2013 Bowman Draft Picks Aaron Judge Rookie Card #BDPP19 make for the best Aaron Judge rookie cards. This card debuted ahead of Judge's MLB career, making it an appealing prospect for collectors and its value has increased significantly over the years due to Judge's rise to stardom. However, remember that the "best" card often depends on your personal preferences, collecting habits, and budget constraints.
How Much is an Aaron Judge Rookie Card Worth?
Determining the exact dollar value of any Aaron Judge rookie card depends on several factors. These factors include the card's condition, the grading it has received from reputable professional grading companies (we only recommend PSA, BGS, and SGC), the variant of the card, and market demand at the time of sale.
For example, the 2013 Bowman Draft Picks Aaron Judge card can range from a few hundred to several tens of thousand dollars, depending on its condition and grading. In contrast, the 2017 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge card might cost anywhere from thirty to eighty dollars.
Of course, these dollar values can fluctuate over time. An exceptional season or playoff series from Judge, a milestone career achievement, or even his eventual retirement (or having his number retired) can lead to significant value changes for his rookie cards.
Collecting rookie cards of Yankees slugger Aaron Judge can be both an exciting hobby and a potentially lucrative investment. However, it's extremely important to be careful and realistic when purchasing baseball cards with the belief that their value will continue to increase over time. Always do your research , verify the authenticity and condition of any cards you choose to purchase, and consult reliable pricing guides to ensure you're making an informed decision.
Finally, remember that while the value of rookie cards can rise, they can also fall and never recover to their highest values. Yet, for the true fan, the joy of owning a piece of baseball history can be priceless.
Disclaimer: This article is intended to honor and showcase the most sought-after rookie cards of Aaron Judge. It should not be interpreted as financial or investment guidance. When engaging in sports card investments, it's crucial to evaluate the condition and grading of the card and to buy from trustworthy vendors. The card prices can undergo substantial fluctuations, influenced by factors like the card's state, market demand, and grading.
The Mathematics of Major League Baseball
Learn how to calculate popular baseball statistics including batting average, on-base percentage, earned run average, and more!
Search Tags: aaron judge rookie card, aaron judge rookie cards, aaron judge topps rookie card, aaron judge rookie card topps, aaron judge rookie card value, aaron judge bowman rookie card, topps aaron judge rookie card, how much is a aaron judge rookie card worth, best aaron judge rookie card, best aaron judge rookie cards
Since then, the value of his rookie cards have continued to climb over the years and early investors were further rewarded in 2022 when Judge blasted 62 home runs, breaking the American League single-season record and earning him his first career MVP award.What are the most sought after Aaron Judge cards? ›
The most valuable Card of Aaron Judge is currently 2013 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects Chrome Draft Pick Autographs Blue Refractors #BCA-AJ Aaron Judge /99 BGS 9.5 by Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects from 2013 with a worth of approx. $25000.0.How much is Derek Jeter rookie card worth? ›
Article snapshot. Derek Jeter rookie cards are some of the most highly sought after cards for any collector. The 1993 Upper Deck SP Derek Jeter rookie card is the most valuable, with a maximum sale price of $600,000.What Bryce Harper cards are rare? ›
There are currently 14954 Cards of Bryce Harper in our Database including 1 rookie Cards and 12271 variations Cards. The most valuable Card of Bryce Harper is currently 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects Refractors #BCP1 Bryce Harper /799 PSA 10 by Bowman from 2011 with a worth of approx. $7500.0.What is the rarest Aaron Judge rookie card? ›
Aaron Judge's 2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks rookie card #BCAAJ has its highest sale price at $8,500. Aaron Judge's 2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks autograph is a must-have. It's the holy grail for fans of the New York Yankee slugger, creating a frenzy for collectors.What is the most expensive rookie card right now? ›
While Honus Wagner's card is generally seen as the holy grail for baseball card fans, it's Mantle's rookie that takes the top spot. On August 28 of 2022, a Mickey Mantle 1952 Topps Card sold for $12.6 million to an anonymous buyer.Who is the most sought after baseball card? ›
The current record price is the US$12.6 million paid for a 1952 Mickey Mantle baseball card (Topps; #311) on August 28, 2022, breaking all previous records.What pick did Aaron Judge go? ›
The Yankees drafted Judge in the first round of the 2013 MLB draft with the 32nd overall selection, a pick the team received as compensation after losing Nick Swisher in free agency. Judge signed with the Yankees and received a $1.8 million signing bonus.How much did Hank Aaron rookie card sell for? ›
Hank Aaron 1954 Rookie Card Sells for $170,000 at Auction.What are Michael Jordan rookie cards worth? ›
In the current market, and at grade 9, this rookie card ranges from $10,000 to $20,000. 1986-87 Fleer #57 Michael Jordan graded CSG 1. Lower graded examples of the 1986-87 Fleer #57 still enjoy a robust market, with a grade 1 selling for around $1,500 to $2,000.
The average value of "ken griffey rookie card" is $32.72. Sold comparables range in price from a low of $1.95 to a high of $905.10.Which Ken Griffey Jr cards are worth money? ›
- Ken Griffey Jr. 1998 Upper Deck A Piece Of Action Patch Auto /24 BGS 8.5 - $84,000. ...
- Ken Griffey Jr. / Mickey Mantle 1994 Upper Deck Dual Signed Card BGS 9.5/AUTO 10 - $57,600. CardLadder. ...
- Ken Griffey Jr. ...
- Ken Griffey Jr. ...
- Ken Griffey Jr. ...
- Ken Griffey Jr. ...
- Ken Griffey Jr. ...
- Ken Griffey Jr.
The Stephen Curry Autographed National Treasures Logoman Rookie Card…has recently been sold for a staggering $5.9 million, making it the most expensive basketball card ever sold.Who has the rarest card? ›
The title of 'world's rarest trading card' is split between two quite distinct cards: the 1996 World Champion and the Shichifukujin Dragon. Only one specimen of each card exists anywhere in the world.How rare is a Tom Brady rookie card? ›
The 2000 Bowman Tom Brady gold rookie card #236 is the kind of collectible many football card enthusiasts would die for. Making it even more special, these cards are a rare find, numbered at just 99. One of those sold for an eye-popping $288,000 at Heritage Auctions on November 18, 2021. But it's not all about money.Who has the most expensive rookie card in the NBA? ›
The unique 2009-10 Stephen Curry Autographed National Treasures Logoman Rookie card sold for $5.9 million in July 2021, making it the second most valuable sports card ever behind Honus Wagner's $6.6 million baseball card.How rare is Babe Ruth rookie card? ›
Much rarer than the 1915 rookie card, few 1914 Ruth cards remain in circulation—only 10 are known to exist. Just three of them are PSA-graded, with the highest quality being a PSA-4 valued at $2.5 million.What is Julio Rodriguez rookie card? ›
2022 Topps Series 2 1987 Topps Baseball Autographs Julio Rodriguez #87BA-JRO. This is the first live Julio Rodriguez autograph card available in packs following his MLB debut. Signed on-card, it's fashioned after the often-used 1987 Topps Baseball design.What baseball cards are hot right now? ›
- 2022 Bowman Baseball. Bowman is a big name when it comes to baseball cards, and their 2022 collection is in high demand. ...
- 2022 Topps Heritage. ...
- 2022 Topps Inception. ...
- 2022 Bowman First Edition. ...
- 2022 Topps Gypsy Queen. ...
- 2022 Topps Series 1. ...
- 2022 Topps Opening Day.
The 1986/87 Fleer Michael Jordan #57 RC is one of the most sought-after cards in the world. It has been described as "the holy grail" and is considered one of the rarest basketball cards in existence.
- Best Overall: Mickey Mantle 1952 Topps Rookie Card.
- Best Rookie Card: Luka Doncic.
- Best NFL Card: Tom Brady Optic Base.
- Best Classic Movie Cards: Star Wars.
- Best Animated Cards: Pokémon.
A mint-condition Mickey Mantle baseball card has sold for a record-breaking $12.6 million. A mint-condition Mickey Mantle baseball card sold for $12.6 million on Sunday, the most money ever paid for a piece of sports memorabilia in a market that has grown exponentially more lucrative in recent years.How do I know if my sports cards are worth money? ›
To find the value of sports cards, there is no better source than eBay. eBay will show you exactly what a particular card in a variety of conditions has recently sold for.How do I know if my baseball cards are worth money? ›
Specialists appraise baseball cards based on numerous factors, including overall condition, rarity, scarcity, grading, print variation, print quality, and, of course, the person featured on the card. Combined, these characteristics can determine the price and worth of a baseball card.Who has the best chance of getting Aaron Judge? ›
|San Francisco Giants||+115||46.5%|
|New York Yankees||+150||40.0%|
|Los Angeles Dodgers||+750||16.7%|
|Boston Red Sox||+950||9.5%|
But the 2013 first-round draft pick is the #2 prospect in the New York Yankees farm system and the top prospect the Yankees picked in the 2013 draft joining fellow 2013 first round picks Eric Jagielo and Ian Clarkin in our top 20 prospect list.What did Aaron Judge get offered? ›
New York Yankees star Aaron Judge turned down an offer this offseason worth more than $400 million from the San Diego Padres, Judge's agents told The Athletic. Here's what you need to know: Page Odle of PSI Sports Management says the offer from San Diego was worth more than $400 million.Are Bo Jackson cards worth anything? ›
The average value of "bo jackson card" is $13.43. Sold comparables range in price from a low of $0.99 to a high of $3,003.50.Why is Mike Trout rookie card so valuable? ›
Trout's rookie card is relatively scarce
and others who had their cards produced in the mass production or “junk wax era” there are simply going to be a lot more of those cards available.
The most valuable Card of Hank Aaron is currently 1954 Topps #128 Hank Aaron PSA 9 by Topps from 1954 with a worth of approx. $720000.0.
The card comes in different tiers (just like Flair) including bronze, silver, and gold versions, and is a part of the Finest Series 1 Apprentices subset. Kobe's 1996 Finest Refractor rookie cards are worth anywhere from $1,000 to $30,000. One card even sold for a jaw-dropping $50,000 in August 2020.What is the rarest Michael Jordan card? ›
- 1984 Star #101 Michael Jordan BGS 8.5.
- 1986 Fleer #57 Michael Jordan SGC 10.
- 1986 Fleer Stickers #8 Michael Jordan PSA 10.
- 1996 SPx #8 Michael Jordan PSA 8.
- 1988 Fleer Stickers #7 Michael Jordan PSA 10.
- 1984 Star #288 Michael Jordan BGS 9.
1984-85 Star Michael Jordan PSA 9: $444,000
It features action from his rookie campaign, a season where Mike averaged 28.3 PPG. This card currently stands as a POP 1, and none have been graded higher. The Star set was often handed out as a promotional tool during Bulls games, so a PSA 10 grade will be hard to come by.
About Darryl Strawberry
The most valuable Card of Darryl Strawberry is currently 1984 Topps Tiffany #182 Darryl Strawberry PSA 10 by Topps from 1984 with a worth of approx. $944.0.
- 1987 Topps #366 Mark McGwire by Topps from 1987 with a value of approx. $1.0.
- 1985 Topps #401 Mark McGwire by Topps from 1985 with a value of approx. $8.0.
- 1988 Topps #580 Mark McGwire by Topps from 1988 with a value of approx. $1.99.
Nolan Ryan 1973 Topps #220 PSA 10 – $70,961
Ryan had a phenomenal year with the west coast ballclub, finishing second in the A.L. Cy Young voting. This card, which is limited to just six PSA 10 copies, sold for as high as $70,691 during a January 2023 auction.
All 1989 Topps Baseball Cards
The most valuable card of 1989 Topps is currently 1989 Topps Tiffany #647 Randy Johnson PSA 10 with a worth of approx. $1,525.00. The most traded card of 1989 Topps in the past 30 days on eBay was for 1989 Topps #647 Randy Johnson with 32 trades and an average price of $1.28.
Many ungraded Bonds rookies can be bought for under $1. At the same time, highly collectible graded cards like a 1986 Topps Traded Tiffany or the 1987 Topps Tiffany and OPC singles, can hardly be found for under $3,000.What is the most expensive Bo Jackson card? ›
- Price Range: $283 to $600.
- Highest Sale Price: $1,500.
- PSA 10 Supply: 31.
- Type: Finest All-star set.
1909-1911 Honus Wagner T206
Considered the rarest and most valuable baseball card in existence, there are only about 50 copies of this full-color card from 1909 to 1911, known as the T206 Wagner. In 2016, one sold at auction for $3.12 million.
High-value cards to invest in for 2023 include the 1985 Michael Jordan Nike Promo, 1986 Michael Jordan Fleer RC #57, 1996 Kobe Bryant Topps Chrome RC #138, and 2018 Luka Doncic Panini Prizm RC #280.What 90s basketball cards are worth money? ›
- 1997-98 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Emerald Tim Duncan #66 - $218,400.
- 1998-99 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Michael Jordan #1 - $192,000. ...
- 1998-99 Metal Universe Championship Precious Metal Gems Kobe Bryant #86 - $144,000. ...
Secret Rare. Secret rare cards are cards with set numbers outside the printed size of the set (for example, a card numbered 101/100).What is the oldest card in the world? ›
The oldest surviving cards in the world are four fragments found in the Keir Collection and one in the Benaki Museum. They are dated to the 12th and 13th centuries (late Fatimid, Ayyubid, and early Mamluk periods).Who is the most popular card? ›
The Ace of Spades (also known as the Spadille and Death Card) is traditionally the highest and most valued card in the deck of playing cards in English-speaking countries.Is there a million dollar football card? ›
That was proven in July 2021 when a 2017 Panini National Treasures Platinum #161 Patrick Mahomes II NFL Shield Rookie Autograph 1/1 became the single most expensive football card ever sold, fetching an astounding $4.3 million in a private sale.How much is a 1 1 card worth? ›
Like most cards, the value of 1/1 cards is going to depend on a number of factors, and can vary from something as low as a few dollars to tens of thousands of dollars. Factors like player, set, type of 1/1 (auto or plate), rookie year, and more will all be value determining factors of the worth of a 1/1.What is a LeBron James rookie card worth? ›
The rare 2003 Ultimate Collection Ultimate Logos Signature Card is valued at over $300,000. A 2012 Panini Prizm Gold LeBron James Rookie Card fetched $571,000 in 2021. The 2003 Topps Chrome LeBron James Black Refractor Rookie Card sold for $480,000.Will Kobe rookie cards increase in value? ›
Since the devastating passing of Kobe Bryant in January of 2020, his rookie cards have seen a significant increase in value. While it can feel strange to think that Kobe's passing has financial gains associated with it, it does, in fact, matter to collectors.Are rookie cards worth more signed? ›
The decades-old argument about getting a player's autograph on his rookie card continues to rage, only nowadays it isn't necessarily considered taboo. A player's signature on his rookie card – or any card, for that matter – can actually add value, certainly sentimentally if not financially.
In 2010, when he was 18 years old, Judge was selected in the Major League Baseball amateur draft by the Oakland A's.Why are rookie cards the most valuable? ›
Rookie cards are worth more than other cards of the same player because they were historically scarcer and harder to come by in top condition than cards issued later in a player's career.How much is a Michael Jordan rookie card worth? ›
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $250,000
The most desirable and widely considered to be "the Jordan rookie" is his 1986 Fleer issue. As mentioned previously, Fleer distributed these on a mass scale so they're not even that scarce.
It's a cornerstone of any Michael Jordan collection, and can sell for tens of thousands of dollars. In the current market, and at grade 9, this rookie card ranges from $10,000 to $20,000. 1986-87 Fleer #57 Michael Jordan graded CSG 1.Are serial numbered cards worth more? ›
The more low-numbered a card is, the more it is worth. This, in particular, is true in relation to the other cards of the set. For example, a /99 Prizm of LeBron will be worth more than a /199 Prizm of LeBron. The catch is that there are times when different brands have different values despite the numbering.Should I get rookie cards graded? ›
So being conservative is always essential when thinking about submitting for grading. In addition to adding value, a graded card provides much better liquidity. If you need to sell your card, the chances are (considering equal grades) that a graded copy will sell for more money than a raw copy.How much is a Tom Brady rookie card worth signed? ›
An autographed Brady rookie card just sold for $2.4 million at a public auction, according to TMZ Sports. The Brady rookie card, which was from the 2000 Playoff Contenders Championship Ticket set, is the highest sale for any football card at a public auction in 2022.Who was the oldest rookie? ›
Morris was signed in December 2000 to a minor-league contract by the Los Angeles Dodgers, but was released during spring training. At the end of his major league career he was 0–0 with an ERA of 4.80 and 13 strikeouts. Morris has released an autobiography, The Oldest Rookie. He often appears as a motivational speaker.Who is the oldest rookie of the years? ›
Sam Jethroe is the oldest player to have won the award, at age 32, 33 days older than 2000 winner Kazuhiro Sasaki (also 32).Where was Aaron Judge ranked as a prospect? ›
June 8, 2013: Yankees draft Aaron Judge. Going into the 2013 draft, Baseball America ranked Judge as the 30th-best prospect in the class. His raw power was obvious, and he hit .
It is generally agreed that to be a true rookie card, the card must be counted as part of a product's base set. Thus, limited quantity insert cards of any type are generally not considered to be rookie cards.What is the most sought after baseball card? ›
The most valuable baseball card of all, the 1911 American Tobacco Company card of Honus Wagner. Star power: Known as "The Flying Dutchman," Wagner had 3,420 hits and 723 stolen bases in his career with the Louisville Colonels and Pittsburgh Pirates from 1897-1917.What is the most valuable rookie card from the 90s? ›
The 1993 SP Derek Jeter #279 rookie card's foil edition is the most valuable from the nineties. A Gem grade card of his costs $360,000, as per PSA valuation.